BucketMate vs Cyberduck: S3 GUI Comparison
BucketMate vs Cyberduck is the usual choice when someone wants an S3 GUI for macOS. Both can reach Amazon S3 and S3-compatible storage like Cloudflare R2 and MinIO, but they take different approaches.
- Cyberduck is a free, multi-protocol storage browser (S3, FTP/SFTP, WebDAV, cloud drives, and more). Breadth is the superpower.
- BucketMate is an S3-focused client for macOS and Web built around a modern UI with great simplicity, and powerful multi-provider features behind the scenes.
If you need every remote protocol in one free app, Cyberduck is hard to beat. If you want daily S3 work to feel calm and modern without losing depth, BucketMate is the clearer fit.
Quick verdict
| If you need… | Prefer |
|---|---|
| Free multi-protocol browser (FTP + S3 + drives) | Cyberduck |
| Simple modern S3 UI with power underneath | BucketMate |
| Zero budget and occasional S3 uploads | Cyberduck (or BucketMate free plan) |
| Web app + native Mac for the same S3 accounts | BucketMate |
| Finder mount of remote storage | Neither alone - look at Mountain Duck (Cyberduck ecosystem) |
Side-by-side overview
| BucketMate | Cyberduck | |
|---|---|---|
| Product bet | Simple modern S3 UX + power behind the scenes | Free multi-protocol browser |
| Platforms | macOS, iOS + Web | macOS + Windows |
| AWS S3 / R2 / MinIO / B2 / Spaces | Yes (hub-style providers) | Yes (via S3 and related profiles) |
| FTP / SFTP / WebDAV | No | Yes |
| Google Drive / OneDrive / Dropbox | No | Yes |
| Default UI feel | Clean, S3-first, modern | Utilitarian, protocol-rich |
| Workspaces / multi-account S3 focus | First-class | Bookmarks (flexible, less S3-specific) |
| Inline previews | Yes | Limited |
| Presigned share links | Built-in product flow | Possible depending on setup |
| Finder disk mount | No | Via Mountain Duck (separate app) |
| Pricing | Free plan + one-time Pro | Free / donationware |
| Best for | Multi-cloud S3 with simple daily UX | Users who need many protocols free |
Where Cyberduck wins
1) Price and openness
Cyberduck is free and open source. If your only requirement is “open this S3 bucket without paying,” it is a safe default.
2) Protocol breadth
Need FTP to a legacy host and S3 and WebDAV in one app? Cyberduck is built for that. BucketMate intentionally does not try to be every protocol - that is how it stays simple.
3) Ecosystem with Mountain Duck
Teams that already use Cyberduck bookmarks often add Mountain Duck to mount remotes in Finder. That browse + mount combo is a mature story BucketMate does not replace.
Where BucketMate wins
1) Modern simplicity (the main product bet)
BucketMate is designed so everyday S3 work feels obvious: browse, upload, download, move on. The UI should not feel like a control panel from 2012 or a browser full of admin chrome.
2) Power behind the scenes
When you need more than basic transfers, the deeper tools are already there - without covering the default screen:
- Multi-provider hub (R2 + S3 + MinIO + more in one place)
- Workspaces and pinned buckets
- Local-first search
- Inline previews
- Presigned share links
That is the opposite of “show every feature as a toolbar icon.”
3) Multi-cloud object storage without tab chaos
Connect AWS S3, Cloudflare R2, local MinIO, Backblaze B2, DigitalOcean Spaces, Supabase Storage, Hetzner Object Storage, and Tigris in one hub. That matches how many indie and startup stacks look in 2026.
4) Native macOS + Web
Cyberduck is a desktop browser. BucketMate ships a native Mac app and a Web app for the same class of S3 work when you are not on your laptop.
5) Commercial model that matches the product
Free plan to try the simple experience; one-time Pro for macOS / Web / Universal - not a subscription just to keep a desktop S3 tool. See pricing.
Feature detail for S3 users
| Task | BucketMate | Cyberduck |
|---|---|---|
| Calm, modern daily browsing | Core pitch | Utilitarian |
| Drag-and-drop upload / download | Yes | Yes |
| Custom S3 endpoint (R2, MinIO) | Yes | Yes |
| Multiple S3-compatible accounts | First-class hub | Bookmarks |
| Bucket-oriented workspaces | Yes | Manual organization |
| Fast search in UI | Product focus | Basic browsing |
| Generate share / presigned URLs | Built-in | Not the main workflow |
| FTP / non-S3 protocols | No (keeps UX focused) | Yes (core strength) |
| Scripting / automation | Pair with CLI | Pair with CLI |
Neither app replaces aws, rclone, or mc for CI. Keep the CLI for pipelines; use a GUI for interactive work.
Connecting Cloudflare R2 in Cyberduck vs BucketMate
Both apps reach R2 over its S3 API with the same three values: the endpoint https://<account-id>.r2.cloudflarestorage.com, an R2 API token's Access Key ID and Secret, and region auto. The difference is how much setup sits around them.
Cyberduck with Cloudflare R2
- Install the Cloudflare R2 Storage (S3) connection profile from Preferences → Profiles (or open a bookmark with the Amazon S3 type).
- Set Server to
<account-id>.r2.cloudflarestorage.com. - Paste the Access Key ID and Secret from your R2 API token.
- If the token is scoped to Object Read & Write with no bucket listing, put the bucket name in the bookmark's Path field.
Cyberduck's own R2 docs list pre-signed URLs as unsupported for R2, so sharing a private object needs another tool.
BucketMate with Cloudflare R2
- Click Add connection → Cloudflare R2.
- Paste the endpoint, access key, and secret. Region is
auto. - If the token cannot list buckets, turn off "Credentials have permission to list buckets" and type the bucket names.
- Test connection and save. The same connection works on Mac, iOS, and Web.
Presigned share links, previews, and drag-and-drop work on R2 the same way they do on AWS S3. Full walkthrough with screenshots: Cloudflare R2 GUI for macOS.
Using Cyberduck with S3-compatible storage (MinIO, Wasabi, B2)
Cyberduck reaches S3-compatible providers through connection profiles. You pick the right profile, then fill in the provider's hostname and keys. BucketMate lists the common providers directly in Add connection and falls back to Other for any custom endpoint.
| Setup step | Cyberduck | BucketMate |
|---|---|---|
| Pick provider | Install a provider profile or use generic Amazon S3 / S3 (HTTP) | Choose from the provider list (R2, MinIO, Wasabi, B2, Spaces, Supabase, Hetzner, Tigris, Other) |
| Endpoint config | Server hostname per bookmark | Endpoint URL per connection |
| Local MinIO over plain HTTP | Needs the S3 (HTTP) profile | Enter http://127.0.0.1:9000 |
| Profile download needed | Often, for provider defaults | No |
| Token without bucket listing | Bucket name in Path | Toggle off bucket listing, enter bucket names |
| Several providers at once | One bookmark per account | One sidebar with every connection |
Running MinIO on your Mac? Start with MinIO on macOS: local S3 bucket setup, then connect it in either app.
Pricing comparison
| BucketMate | Cyberduck | |
|---|---|---|
| Free usage | Free plan with limits | Full free desktop app |
| Paid unlock | One-time Pro (macOS / Web / Universal options) | Optional donation / related paid apps (e.g. Mountain Duck) |
| Ongoing fee for core GUI | No subscription required for Pro | No for Cyberduck itself |
If “$0 forever for every protocol” is the goal, Cyberduck wins. If “simple modern S3 UI free to try, pay once for full power” is the goal, BucketMate fits.
Performance and UX notes
- Cyberduck is reliable and familiar. The UI is utilitarian - great for occasional multi-protocol work, less delightful for all-day multi-bucket S3 ops.
- BucketMate targets native feel, lower friction browsing, and S3-specific flows - simplicity on top, power underneath.
Exact throughput depends on network, object size, and API limits. For bulk sync jobs, measure both against rclone/aws s3 sync before standardizing.
Migration: Cyberduck → BucketMate (or both)
You do not migrate data out of Cyberduck. You only bring your connections, and BucketMate for Mac can import them:
- In BucketMate, open the connection form and choose Import from another app → Cyberduck.
- Pick your Cyberduck bookmarks. BucketMate reads only the files you choose.
- Review the list, add each secret key (or let BucketMate look it up in Keychain with your permission), and choose Import.
- Test list + a small upload on a safe prefix.
- Keep Cyberduck for FTP if you still need it; use BucketMate for daily S3/R2/MinIO.
Using rclone too? The same import reads your rclone remotes.
Guides:
Who should use which?
Choose Cyberduck if you
- Need FTP/SFTP/WebDAV/Drive in the same app
- Want a free, battle-tested multi-protocol client
- Already standardize the team on Cyberduck bookmarks
Choose BucketMate if you
- Want a modern simple UI with powerful S3 tools underneath
- Live in S3-compatible object storage (especially multi-cloud)
- Want previews, share links, workspaces, and a Web option
- Prefer a free plan + one-time Pro over another “everything remote” tool
Use both if you
- Still have FTP servers and a serious R2/S3/MinIO workload
- Want Mountain Duck mounts for some paths and a dedicated simple S3 GUI for the rest
FAQ
Is BucketMate a Cyberduck alternative?
Yes, for S3-compatible object storage - especially if you care about simple modern UX. It is not a full Cyberduck alternative for FTP, WebDAV, or consumer cloud drives.
Is Cyberduck better for Cloudflare R2?
Both can connect to R2 via the S3 API. Prefer Cyberduck if you already use it for everything else. Prefer BucketMate if you want a cleaner R2/S3 multi-provider product for daily work, plus presigned share links on R2.
How do I connect Cloudflare R2 in Cyberduck?
Install the Cloudflare R2 Storage (S3) profile from Preferences → Profiles, set Server to <account-id>.r2.cloudflarestorage.com, and paste your R2 API token's Access Key ID and Secret. If the token cannot list buckets, add the bucket name to the bookmark Path.
Does Cyberduck work with S3-compatible storage like MinIO, Wasabi, and B2?
Yes, through connection profiles. Use a provider profile or the generic Amazon S3 profile with a custom server, and the S3 (HTTP) profile for a local MinIO without TLS. BucketMate connects to the same providers from its built-in provider list.
Is Cyberduck an Amazon S3 client?
Yes. Amazon S3 is one of many Cyberduck protocols, next to FTP, SFTP, WebDAV, and cloud drives. Amazon S3 is the storage service and Cyberduck is one of the clients that browse it, the same job BucketMate does with an S3-only focus.
What is the best Cyberduck alternative for S3 on Mac?
For S3, R2, and MinIO work, BucketMate is a focused Cyberduck alternative with a native Mac app, an iOS app, and a Web app. For other options, see best S3 GUI for macOS.
Does BucketMate replace Mountain Duck?
No. Mountain Duck mounts storage in Finder. BucketMate is a bucket browser/manager with power features behind the scenes. Different jobs. More in Mountain Duck vs BucketMate.
Can I use BucketMate for free like Cyberduck?
BucketMate has a free plan with limits so you can try the simple modern UI first. Cyberduck’s desktop app is free without that product model. Compare current limits on BucketMate pricing.